Mental health apps have become part of many people's routines: emotional journals, meditation apps, chatbots that offer to "talk" and online therapy platforms. They can help. But the information shared in them, thoughts, fears, mood and sometimes details about family and work, is among the most sensitive there is. Before you start writing, it's worth checking what happens to it.
Why does it matter?
The most prominent case is BetterHelp, one of the world's largest online therapy platforms. In 2023 the US Federal Trade Commission (FTC) found that the company shared users' information with advertisers, including email addresses and answers to mental health questionnaires, with companies such as Facebook and Snapchat, despite promising to protect it. The company paid $7.8 million for user refunds and was banned from sharing health data for advertising. BetterHelp said it did not share clinical data and that the settlement is not an admission of wrongdoing. But the case showed how valuable this data is.
Question one: who sees what I write?
This is the most important question. A good app should store content encrypted, so that even if its servers are breached, the content itself isn't exposed. Look in the privacy policy for the words "encryption" and "encrypted," and check whether the company explains who can access the content: can its employees read it? Outside vendors?
Question two: is the content sent to AI?
Many apps now add AI features: summaries, insights, "mood analysis." That can be useful, but it also usually means your personal text is sent to a language model run by another company. Check whether content is used to train models, whether it is stored by the AI provider, and whether those features can be turned off. Some apps have deliberately chosen not to apply AI to the content itself. For example, a private emotional journal such as NestAI states that content is stored encrypted, and that it does not send it to a language model, analyze it or generate summaries from it.
Question three: what about advertising and sharing?
Read in the privacy policy whether the company shares information with "partners" or "third parties," and for what purpose. Ad network tracking tools embedded in an app can send information about your usage even if the company doesn't intend it. An app that lives on advertising is a higher risk than one that lives on subscriptions.
Question four: can I delete everything?
Check whether you can export your data and delete the account entirely, and what happens to the data after deletion. A fair app lets you leave easily and deletes the content, rather than just "deactivating" the account.
And what does the law say?
In the US, most consumer mental health apps are not covered by the medical privacy law (HIPAA), which applies mainly to health providers such as therapists and insurers. In Israel, information about mental state is defined under the Privacy Protection Law as sensitive information, but enforcement against foreign apps is limited. The upshot: responsibility for checking largely stays with the user.
A short checklist before you start
Encryption of content; a clear explanation of who can access it; whether content is sent to AI, and whether that can be turned off; whether there is sharing with advertisers; the ability to export and delete. And beyond technology: lock your phone, and use a passcode or biometrics for the app itself. Those keeping a journal between therapy sessions can find ideas for structure and questions in the same app's guides.
The bottom line
Mental health apps can be a good aid, but they are not therapy and don't replace a professional. And before sharing your most personal thoughts in them, it's worth spending ten minutes checking privacy. Anyone in emotional distress in Israel can call ERAN, the emotional first aid line, at 1201, at any hour.
